I read the product details & ordered it from nykaa website, after some days use I realised it was not so smudge proof,& when I need to sharpen,it's to hard for sharpening..now the pencil is useless...so what to do? Please answer my comment plum

Kajal was superb. It’s lasted for more then 12hours in a rainy hot humid climate in Goa. It has a glides smoothly. Nd I had no rashes. No regrets buying it.

I purchased this product from purplle after reading all the reviews about this kajal and was excited too.. but it did not meet the expectations .the color is dark black and looks highly pigmented but one can not say it is 100% smudge proof it does smudge and that too with 4-5 hours after applying and the stay is also on an average side. the worst part is whenever I sharp it , the kajal breaks down and that happens every time so I have to sharp it very very carefully and this resulted in lots of product wastage and money wastage.

My first Plum purchase and I am super happy. Perfect combination of features - color, cost, cruelty-free and chutzpah...

I really superlike the kajal...its completely smudge free and lasts long in eyes. I received my third kajal today, but what disappoints me a lot is that the pencil gets over soon. Towards the end of it, not able to sharpen as the pencil shortens. Feel really bad that though paying a good amount for it, we are unable to utilize it completely. Hope plum considers the roll on/roll back kajal

Good intense colour but sharpener could be better .

I bought it just for a try... but now I love it like anything... I use it as wicked kajal.. liner... it's awesome.. simply elegant... soft yo eyes... most important weight less..

It was a huge relief using this kohl kaajal. But it will get over very fast, as need to rub it real hard to get the dark black effect. Havent sharpened it yet, hope it will not keep breaking while doing so. When will you all come up with Vegan lipsticks?

kajal is awsumm not too wax and light on eyes smudge free only one thing is that u need to rub more to get dark black color on eyes

And it irritates my eye... I didn't have a proven sensitivity for eyeliner/Kajal I use most brands without any issues
I bought this because it said smudge proof and gel like spread etc ... but it disappointed me

I tried your Kajal pencil and am a very satisfied customer. It works much better as an eyeliner than Kajal. It stays on perfectly well right through the day, and suffered a crying spell without moving from its place. I only wish it was not a sharpening pencil;that i find an inconvenience as the sharpener must be carried too. An absolutely five star product. Thank you.

The Plum Kajal is very smooth n dark...n the best part is it is smudge free n lasts very long....loved it!

It is not smudge free and the nib breaks off easily when sharpening the pencil.

I really liked plum kajal as it's very black the way I wanted the texture is very smooth and long lasting and smudgeproof

Loved the Kajal now I use it on my baby .. it doesn't pull the skin n hurt her ... is darker and stays longer .... am very happy with my buy

Very disappointed. The Kajal is just not black enough. Also it des not stay as claimed .
Total waste of money!

Perfect kajal indeed! It's an awesome product definitely. After trials with many other kajals i found this one finally which suited my eyes. It's dark,smooth,smudge free. Thanks plum goodness!

Very good product, as mentioned smudge proof, dark black shade, sits perfectly, longggggg lasting, I apply it at 8 45am and remove at 7pm, it stays all day perfectly, till I actually take it off using make up remover. It stays the same whole day.
I suggested the same to my colleagues also.

Really loved the kajal. Dsnt cause eye irritation n watering prblm is not any more Really loved it

Smudge proof, long lasting, dramatic eye. An awsome product. I never saw any kajal like this. love this product buy again again and again... Thanku plum

This kajal has become my favourite now it is one of the best kajal I liked it very much ... Thank u plum for such a wonderful kajal

Forget about quality atleast give a safe to use product! Used it twice and both the time had eye infection! Had used many kajal from branded to non-branded but never this happened! Harmful product!

This kohl is amazing. It won't move at all. I've very oily eyelids and nothing stays there, but naturstudio stayed there for more than eight hours. It has my vote of confidence!

The product is gud... Smudge proof
But its written that sharpner is free and on the bill its written sharpner rs150 and kajal 395... so i didnt gt this.

It is awesome. .liked it

It's awesome , long lasting kajal even for the small eyes n doesn't get smudge.

It's truly amazing

I recommend, doesn't smudge easily. Stays for more than an 8 hrs!

It is smudge proof and stays longer....but not longer than4 to5 hr on my eyes

I liked this Kajal. Its better than its counterparts but it doesn't last more than 2-3 hours. Other Kajal smudge in 30 minutes to 1 HR. It stays a bit longer

Smudge proof. Kajal.. Best product.... Loving it...

Love it! Been two years since i am using this and only this. It's exactly as described.

Jet Black smudge proof Kajal. Loving it

Feeling very sad to write bad review about this Kajal. I decided to buy this kajal after checking so many good reviews. But it did not work for me. Its leaving my eyes dry. Eyes are itching so much since one application. I have stopped using it. This must be good kajal but may not work for everyone.

Awesome pencil..would love to use it again..infact the best!!thumbs up

I have never used so amazing Kajal before this.I am in love with it

This one truly doesn't smudge, the first one I met that really worked!

as i give one star because product doesn't suits me.. if u have allergy to any brand.. then don't try... because after using this kajal my eyes are swallow.. when i complaint to plum, they offer me to take any product of same price.. so for this plum is best.. nd quality of kajal is good.. because my friend using this kajal and she is satisfied...

This kohl is pretty good, it glides on smoothly. Stays long. The only drawback is while drying a wing it's comparable to the effect given by a gel eyeliner not a liquid eyeliner

The kajal is Ah-mazing.
Its waterproof, smudgeproof, darker.
I simply love it. ❤️

An excellent kajal. I have finally found a kajal that does not smudge for hours.
Thank you Plum

It's really smudge proof Kajal. The o lyrics drawback I found is it could b more dark Bcz to get that intense black look I had to apply twice o thrice. N I liked that Kajal but now when I want one more it's out if stock Plz I want one more me it available as soon as possible..

This Kajal is so smooth. I have very sensitive skin and whenever I apply any kajal, my eyes water for a while before settling. I used this kajal and didn't experience any kind of discomfort. This also lasts for a long time and you actually need to use a cream to wipe it off. Glad I bought this along with the sharpener because it is suited perfectly for this kajal.
In fact, the sharpener cover was broken in the first package I ordered. When I brought this to the notice of the Plum people, they immediately sent me another sharpener along with a complimentary toiletry bag and a mini moisturiser tube!

its amazing it works more than 12 hrs.

Happy birthday plum! Well i had been stalking on this kajal since long and finally ordered it. Nd i must say i regret delaying in getting it. This is a beautiful all day wear kajal that too smudge proof and glides so well.. Nd the sharpener is also worth. I always had a problem of wastage of kajal in sharpening . Wherein thrs literally no wastage with plum kajal. Nd its the darkest shade.. thumbs up from my side. Interested in trying ur other products soon.

My first order with Plum
Amazing kajal black intense goes all day long without smudge.
Very happy with the product.
Love it.

I was using Mac earlier and i just bought this kohl and i became a fan of this product and right after the 1st use i ordered twin pack of this Kajal. Trust me guys they say that it will stay as it is for 12 hours but it does for more than 15 hours with such smoothness. This is a True smudge proof kajal. Awesome Product Ever...

Smooth, soft, sharpens evenly, glides smoothly. Just loved it.

In love with plum goodness,love its all products n kajal is my most fav,one of the best kajal ever and in a reasonable price too.., everyone must try it once

This kajal is totally smudge proof.... Love to wear this.... Will buy it again n again...

Finally i got something that doesnt smudge and blacken your eyes throughout the day. Love the smooth and creamy texture. Really worth the money

I was very happy when i started using it. It seemed an answer to all my kohlic problems!
However, I don't think I will be ordering it a second time, as sharpening this pencil is a nightmare. It doesn't sharpen easily, leads to breakage of the point and hence involves a lot of wastage.

Hii am from U.P ,It's best Kajal for rainy & humid season, it's doesn't smluge at all..

I am from Chennai I love the product very much because it kept it's promise. No smudge all day

I love how smooth this kajal is, soo easy to sharpen as well! But I wouldn't say its entirely smudge free, since it does get smudged at the corner of my eyes which is disappointing!
Long lasting? Definitely yes!! Stayed on even after splashing my face with water more than once! I'd say give it shot & try it :)

I love how smooth this kajal is, soo easy to sharpen as well! But I wouldn't say its entirely smudge free, since it does get smudged at the corner of my eyes which is disappointing! Long lasting? Definitely yes!! Stayed on even after splashing my faces with water more than once! I'd say give it shot & try it :)

It's not worth the price. Every Kajal smudge in my eyes in a hour or 2, so I ordered this but it's same only difference it smudges in 3 hrs. Not huge difference as compare to huge price difference.

The packaging was damn good.When I opened the package it was a welcome surprise.I really loved the way the color purple stood out and when I used the kajal it was everything dat i yearned for.The fact it is vegan friendly and preservative free wants me to try ur other products. Good job team and all d best for all ur future endeavours.

I bought it after seeing several reviews that it didn't smudge..But it smudge..I am not finding any difference between plum and any other brand.so I m not satisfied wd plum kajal

It's become my go to kohl for every eye look now. Need I say more? Love it!

I can't do without a kajal and its an essential part of me. My look for a smudge proof kajal was on and finally it has come to an end with plums brans. I am loving this.

Its deep-drop dark, worth the price !! This was the first kajal that didn't smudge even after 10 hours of use. Loved it !

I ordered my first काजल fm Plum n has never regretted d decision... Its best n smooth... Doesn't scratch my waterline... Doesn't smudge.... It has all what they claim.... Only problem resharpening leads to wastage.... Can anything be done abt that....

Very smooth to apply. Darkest shade of black in just one stroke. In love with this smudge proof kohl kajal..! It's Plum, Plum, Plum all the way..!

I bought the twin pack of this kajal a year ago and received a lovely pouch with it..when I got it I realised that the sharpener was broken in transit and so I called up customer support and informed them of the same.very politely the lady agreed to send me a new sharpener and it arrived promptly the next day.This really pleased me as it's not very often that you get good customer service in India..then when I opened and tried on the kajal I was amazed at how wonderful I was..a rich creamy jet black which didn't smudge all day even when I did tend to rub my eyes at one time and I was pleased to know I had to use it just once a day in the morning and It stayed on till I washed it off in the evening which also meant I was using less of it so one kajal lasted me the entire year..it really is lovely..thank u Plum for making a good product. I must admit that when I first started using it I did face an issue with my eyes feeling dry occasionally but in an couple of weeks that soon cleared up and I love the product. It is a quality product.

good product .... long lasting effectand also does not harm your eyes like other chemical products.. recommended for daily use

It is not smooth and I have to rub it a number of times for it to be visible!! Not satisfied!!

bad experience...I was very exited to take this kohl when I got so many good reviews ..but when I got this I was totally disappointed.. It very hard to apply not smudge proof..sorry but really its disgusting .I have lost my 450

Kajal is good, easy to apply. Smudge proof, but its not water proof.

This is the best kajal i have ever used. Its super pigmented and long lasting. Must try.

i must say this kajal is a game changer my eyes are so sensitive i've tried alot of drugstore and high brands kohl pencils but this one.wheneva i tried to use kajal in my eyes it turns red,headache or sleepyness maybe cause of ingredients but this kajal jus give me a shook no reaction smudge proof intense dark and no reactionsthanks to plum i again started doin kohl black eye which i left for years. Love❤

Really beautiful product n good customer response

The kajal is really smooth and gel like which can both be used as a liner as well.Really loved it!!!!!!!

Satisfactory...they give what they claim

This is the best kajal I have ever used. It literally does whatever it claims..... A must try which eventually take over your favourite kajal place.

The Kajal is really dark and smudge free, smooth to apply. I ordered the pack of 2 kajals. The first one lasted for around 4 months, which is really impressive. However, the 2nd pencil was not good in quality and didn't even last a month. I had to sharp alot because the led was weak and was breaking during sharpening. This was a huge disappointment.

Too smooth, Too long lasting, skin friendly!

Easy to apply, smooth and long lasting! Highly recommended